Gavin Stone (Brett Dalton), a former child star and current has-been, is forced to work at a local church after receiving a 200-hour community service sentence. While there, he pretends to be an avid Christian so he can play the role of Jesus in their annual Easter production Passion Play. However, by reconnecting with his past, revisiting his faith, and meeting a wide array of unique people along the way, he discovers that the most important role of his life is far from the bright lights of Hollywood.